Rebatch Gone Wrong

Here is my miserable story about the soap that is NOT going to make it to the shelf. Several days ago I made a double batch of Oatmeal, Milk & Honey soap and forgot to add the rice bran oil. Even as I was putting the oils together in the pot I was thinking that it was odd that I only had two liquid oils in this soap. I checked what I had written down – and there was my problem. I didn’t check the original recipe, only what I had written down!

Well, after the soap level wasn’t as high as usual in the mold, and the goat’s milk turned the soap orange, I realized my mistake.

I waited about a week to do anything about it because I HATE to re-batch. It’s such a pain. Especially with the enormous batch size that I make. Takes a lot of time, not to mention energy to use the oven. Well, Sunday afternoon was unseasonably cool, so I decided to just try re-melting one of the two logs. I started by cutting the soap into chunks that my salad shooter could process:

Soap chunks

Then, I started feeding the chunks into the salad shooter. I used a pot that was plenty large because the shredded soap takes up a lot of space:

Shredding soap

Next, I added the missing rice bran oil:

Pouring in rice bran oil

I put the pot in the oven at 200 degrees for about four hours. I pulled it out to stir every hour or so. This is what it looked like right before I put it in the mold:

Melted soap looks like cookie dough!

Then I smashed it back into the mold:

Soap in the mold

Tried to cut the soap, and it’s super crumbly now:

Oh great! Botched it again...

I’m guessing either I didn’t cook it long enough, or I should have added some liquid. Either way, Clean the World is about to get another box from me. I’m done messing with it!!

Page with Comments

  1. Bummer! It’s so disappointing! It looks like the final product would be fine if it wasn’t so crumbly. 🙁

  2. Oh, no, what a waste that’d be if it wasn’t for Clean the World! Sounds like something I’d do, though, write something down incorrectly or forget something. I’m like that too.

    I do have to say, I like the way it looks in the first photo, that orange looks like pumpkin pie to me.
    .-= Larissa´s last blog post ..Blogs I Follow- Melinda Lancaster- Author and Poet =-.

  3. Isn’t it sad? Hubby’s advice was to chuck it from the beginning. After I told him how it turned out, he said, “Do I need to say anything?” Um, no.

  4. Oh no! I am sooooo sorry, no fun. I have had two batches, – yes two batches go south on me in the past two days. Not sure what the problem is – and no i don’t rebatch. Ugh!

  5. Oh, no, I feel for you! 🙁 I hate rebatching, it’s a last resort for me. Even when I do it I usually don’t get the results I want so most of my ruined batches go straight in the bin.

  6. Bummer! I feel your pain. I think we’ve all had a batch go wrong at some point in time. The good news is that it’s still luxurious, hand made soap that Clean the World will be thankful for =)

Comments are closed.